Thumbnail

13 Factors to Consider When Hiring a Property Manager

13 Factors to Consider When Hiring a Property Manager

Navigating the complexities of property management requires more than just a keen eye; it demands expertise and strategic insights. This article distills knowledge from seasoned professionals to guide you through the essentials of selecting the ideal property manager. Equip yourself with expert advice to make informed decisions that align with your property's success.

  • Research Property Manager's Experience and Communication
  • Choose Proactive Property Managers
  • Understand Property Manager's Local Market Knowledge
  • Hire Experienced Property Managers
  • Treat Property Manager as Business Partner
  • Align Property Manager with Your Success
  • Evaluate Property Manager's Fees and Communication
  • Prioritize Local Market Knowledge
  • Hire Well-Connected Property Managers
  • Vet Property Manager's Experience and Fees
  • Consider Self-Managing Your Properties
  • Assess Property Manager's Key Qualities
  • Hire Flexible and Well-Rounded Property Managers

Research Property Manager's Experience and Communication

With experience in property management and real estate, the most valuable advice I could give to any person intending to hire a property manager is that they must research their experience and mode of communication. A property manager acts as a bridge between you and your tenants, and their proactive ability to address issues can make or break your investment.

When making this decision, consider the following key areas:

Experience and Specialization - Not all property managers are the same. If you are dealing with residential properties, you need to hire someone with an excellent residential management background. Similarly, if you have commercial properties, it requires a different set of skills altogether.

Tenant Management Approach - A good property manager does not just collect rent but handles tenant screening and conflict resolution with professionalism and fairness. Ask about their tenant retention strategies.

Maintenance and Vendor Relationships - Properties always require maintenance, and a well-connected property manager has reliable contractors on hand who can fix problems quickly at a reasonable price.

Technology and Transparency - In today's world, most property managers use software that streamlines rent collection, maintenance requests, and financial reporting. They need to have a system in place that keeps you informed in real time.

Legal Knowledge and Compliance - Property laws and regulations vary from place to place. Therefore, a manager should be well-versed in local landlord-tenant law to keep you compliant and avoid legal pitfalls.

From my own experience, I've seen that a property manager's ability to communicate and problem-solve efficiently is just as important as their technical skills. A good one will protect your investment, while a bad one can cost you time, money, and unnecessary stress. Take your time, ask for references, and ensure their values align with your expectations before making a decision.

Choose Proactive Property Managers

If I could give one key piece of advice for anyone thinking about hiring a property manager, it would be this: choose a professional who not only solves issues but also predicts them and prevents them from happening. A good property manager should be proactive. They need to ensure everything runs smoothly and help you get the best from your investment.

When making this decision, consider these key factors:

> Ensure they have a proven track record managing properties like yours.

> Clear pricing with no hidden costs is essential.

> They must stay ahead of evolving rental regulations.

> Look for automated booking, maintenance tracking, and financial reporting.

> Strong communication ensures high satisfaction and occupancy.

> Routine inspections prevent costly repairs.

> They should optimize pricing and revenue based on trends.

> Regular reports keep you informed without micromanaging.

In the end, a good property manager should make your tasks easier and increase the value and profit of your investment. Take the time to look at candidates carefully. Check their references and ensure their management style matches your long-term goals.

Johan Hajji
Johan HajjiCEO & Founder, UpperKey

Understand Property Manager's Local Market Knowledge

When considering hiring a property manager, my top piece of advice is to look for someone who understands both your unique property needs and the local market. A good property manager should not only handle the day-to-day operations efficiently but also have the expertise to maximize your property's potential.

Key factors to consider include:

1. Experience and Reputation: Ensure the property management company has a proven track record of success and positive reviews from property owners and tenants alike.

2. Comprehensive Services: Choose a property manager who offers a wide range of services, such as tenant management, maintenance, marketing, and leasing, all tailored to your property's specific needs.

3. Communication and Transparency: It's important to have clear and consistent communication with your property manager. They should provide regular updates on property performance, tenant issues, and financial reporting.

4. Local Market Knowledge: An experienced manager familiar with the local rental market can offer invaluable insights into pricing, trends, and regulations.

At JMK Property Management, we pride ourselves on offering full-service property management solutions that cover all these key factors. Our team is dedicated to ensuring your investment is well-maintained, tenants are satisfied, and your property's performance is optimized. If you'd like more information or have specific questions about how we can support you, feel free to visit https://jmkpropertymanagement.com/. We're here to help you make the best decisions for your investment!

Mehdi Khachani
Mehdi KhachaniChief Executive Officer (CEO), JMK Property Management

Hire Experienced Property Managers

If you're hiring a property manager, the most important thing you can do is find someone with experience handling properties exactly like yours. I worked with a landlord who hired the cheapest property manager without checking their reputation. Within months, they had unpaid rent and maintenance issues piling up. A good property manager should have a solid process for screening tenants, handling repairs in a timely manner, and collecting rent on time. It's also important to test their communication style. If they don't respond quickly, they won't respond quickly to tenants. Checking reviews, asking for references, and making sure they have experience with your type of property can save you a lot of stress in the long run. Taking the time to hire the right person will protect your investment and make owning rental property much easier.

Treat Property Manager as Business Partner

If you're thinking about hiring a property manager, the biggest piece of advice I'd give is to treat it like hiring a business partner, not just a service. This is someone who will be handling your investment, your tenants, and your cash flow-you need to trust them completely.

The first thing to look at is their track record. How many properties do they manage? Do they have experience with properties like yours? Check their reviews, ask for references, and talk to other investors who have used them. A good property manager should have a solid reputation and a history of keeping properties profitable.

Communication is another huge factor. You don't want someone who disappears when problems come up. Ask how often they provide updates, how they handle tenant issues, and how quickly they respond to maintenance requests. A property manager who drags their feet on repairs or tenant concerns can cost you money in the long run.

Fees matter, but don't just go for the cheapest option. Make sure you understand exactly what you're paying for. Some companies nickel and dime you with extra charges for things like maintenance coordination, lease renewals, or even answering tenant calls. Be clear on their fee structure upfront.

Most importantly, find someone who treats your property like their own. A great property manager isn't just collecting rent-they're proactively taking care of the property, keeping good tenants happy, and ensuring your investment stays profitable. If you don't get that feeling from them, keep looking.

Align Property Manager with Your Success

Hiring a Property Manager? Look for One Aligned with Your Success

When considering a property manager, the most important factor to evaluate is how well their approach aligns with your success as a property owner. A great property manager doesn't just perform tasks—they operate with a mindset that prioritizes your investment goals.

Start by understanding their processes, fee structures, and overall philosophy. Do they measure success the same way you do? Look for key indicators such as performance-based fee structures and guarantees that hold them accountable for results. Many property managers charge fees regardless of performance, with no guarantees if things go wrong. The best ones, however, tie their success directly to yours, ensuring they are motivated to maximize your property's potential.

Trust is crucial when handing over the management of what is likely your most valuable asset. A property manager truly aligned with your interests will provide transparency, accountability, and a commitment to long-term success.

While fees and costs matter, they shouldn't be the sole deciding factor. Instead, focus on the value a property manager brings through reliable, proactive, and high-quality management. The wrong choice can derail your investment, but the right one can help it thrive.

Evaluate Property Manager's Fees and Communication

If I'm hiring a property manager, I want someone with experience handling properties like mine, a solid tenant screening process, and clear communication on maintenance and finances. I check their fees upfront, ensure they have a strong marketing strategy to keep vacancies low, and review the contract—especially the termination clause. A manager can save me time, but it's still my investment, so I stay informed and involved.

Prioritize Local Market Knowledge

When considering hiring a property manager, one of the most important factors to look for is local market knowledge. A property manager familiar with the area can effectively navigate pricing, tenant preferences, and neighborhood dynamics, ensuring your property is managed to its full potential. They'll have a better understanding of local laws, rental trends, and the types of tenants likely to be attracted to your property. Equally important is strong communication. A good property manager will keep you informed about your property's status, respond to inquiries promptly, and address any concerns as they arise. Additionally, ensure transparency in fees and services. Choose someone who has a proven track record, positive reviews, and clear, upfront costs to avoid unexpected expenses down the line. This combination of expertise, communication, and transparency will help you make the best decision for your property.

Hire Well-Connected Property Managers

I would recommend hiring someone local enough to be really familiar with the ins and outs of the specific neighborhood where your property is located, but also well-connected enough. A well-connected manager will have trusted contractors, maintenance professionals, and legal advisors on hand to handle repairs, emergencies, and compliance issues without unnecessary delays or inflated costs. Their relationships can save you money and headaches in the long run, ensuring that your property stays in good shape and your tenants remain satisfied. It's not easy to nail down this formula for finding the perfect property manager, but one thing you can do to increase your chances is to talk with other property owners in the area, if you can. Ask them about their experiences with local PMs and get their honest feedback. If you can do this, it will get you much further than just relying on online testimonials, which can be manipulated, unfortunately.

Pete Evering
Pete EveringBusiness Development Manager, Utopia Management

Vet Property Manager's Experience and Fees

One piece of advice for someone considering hiring a property manager is to thoroughly vet their experience, fees, and communication style before signing a contract. A good property manager should have a strong track record, clear fee structures, and a proactive approach to tenant relations and maintenance.

Key factors to consider include how they handle tenant screening, rent collection, property maintenance, and legal compliance. Also, ensure they have local market expertise and can effectively minimize vacancies while maximizing rental income. Choosing the right property manager can save time and stress, but the wrong one can lead to unnecessary expenses and tenant issues.

Consider Self-Managing Your Properties

Before hiring a property manager, consider managing your properties yourself. As a seven-figure real estate investor, I do this, and it doesn't have to be time-consuming. Quick example: I use what I call "tenant empowerment," which is my way of entrusting my tenants with day-to-day problem-solving, like calling the plumber if the sink is leaking. Using this approach, problems get resolved much faster, everyone's happy, and it cuts out the middleman: Me. Ultimately, self-managing your properties can save you money - without taking up a lot of your time.

Ryan Chaw
Ryan ChawFounder and Real Estate Investor, Newbie Real Estate Investing

Assess Property Manager's Key Qualities

If I were hiring a property manager (like myself), I would pay attention to a few key factors: Were they easy to get a hold of? Do they seem organized? Do they inspect the house thoroughly the first time? Are they on time for their appointment? Availability, Organization, Attention to Detail, and Respect for Time are all things I value as a property manager.

Hire Flexible and Well-Rounded Property Managers

Property managers wear many hats, so it is vital to hire a well-rounded individual. Someone who is flexible and can lease/sell one hour to making sure problems are solved for current tenants the next hour. This is on top of making sure their property has excellent curb appeal for both potential and new tenants. Another key factor to look at is if they can think on their feet to make sound decisions.

Copyright © 2025 Featured. All rights reserved.